NEoN Digital Reforms Proposal (Public)
"Lets leave planet GAFAM" by David Revoy from https://degooglisons-internet.org
👀 Overview
This proposal details our approach to implementing digital reforms at NEoN based on our discussions and past experiences doing this kind of work with other initiatives such as lumbug.space, UTAW, VREC and Comic Gewerkschaft.
In this document we propose specific free software technologies which we think will fit your needs. These are technologies that we host for other groups and have the most experience maintaining and supporting. We believe this software suite is a sustainable choice for the new NEoN digital infrastructure and supports the goals of DeGoogle-isation.
The ordering of the document is the priority list, e.g. we would tackle migrating your email before moving on to the websites migration. We see this sequence of tasks as the best to way to “warm up” and take on bigger tasks as we gain more confidence working together.
We recognise that implementing this proposal will require a large commitment from both sides to carry through successfully. We’re looking forward to start this project and to working with you all.
This proposal is still open for feedback, questions and amendments. Please let us know if anything is unclear.
Autonomic Co-operative, October 2022
🐢 About us
Autonomic is a worker-owned cooperative, dedicated to using technology to empower people making a positive difference in the world. Since 2017, we’ve been successfully delivering projects in a range of sectors including renewable energy, labour organising, independent media, feminist research, migrant solidarity activism, sustainable fashion, and arms trade abolition.
Our key values for our own decision-making, as well as our client work, are sustainability, transparency, and privacy – you can read more about our approach on our website. We are a Co-operative Society, registered in the UK with the Financial Conduct Authority.
💗 Joining the Co-op Cloud
We will make use of the Co-op Cloud project to set up the new NEoN digital infrastructure. This is a project initiated by Autonomic and now co-operatively managed by an informal network of tech co-ops and democratically run tech collectives.
The aim of the project is to mutualise the means of setting up new digital infrastructure. This reduces costs, saves time and builds solidarity across the sector. Each user group who chooses to run Co-op Cloud contributes to the digital configuration commons which is made available for the benefit of all.
Please see the strategy statement and blog for more.
🕮 Project overview & description
Each section below deals with a specific digital reform.
Email migration
Gandi is the go-to email provider that Autonomic has used since we started. We continue to recommend it to groups who need a stable and reliable email service.
The web interface provides a modern design for those not using email clients. Gandi provides excellent support, documentation and integrates smoothly with email clients such as Thunderbird.
Using Gandi mail requires migrating NEoNs existing domain name registration (e.g. neondigitalarts.com) to Gandi. This is something we can manage with little downtime.
Given the required number of email addresses required, we believe the Gandi mail account pricing is an affordable option. We can migrate entire mail accounts thanks to imapsync so it is not required to start from scratch on the new inbox.
SoGu, one of the two webmail clients provided by Gandi
Websites migration
As we are only required to provide hosting for NEoNs websites, this phase will be a matter of organising the migration logistics, i.e. when is it a good time to transfer data, switch servers, etc. A migration timeline will be proposed which we can all agree on before starting this process.
Account Management
We make use of a technique called Single Sign On (SSO) which allows NEoN staff to use a single account username and password to log in to each tool. We use a software called Authentik for this. It also provides an online dashboard which is a convenient way to get an overview without having to remember web URLs for each tool.
It is worth noting that that since we do not control access to the Gandi web interface, we cannot implement SSO for mail accounts. However, in practice, this isn’t an issue since you log in to your account on Thunderbird once and don’t have to deal with account details very often again.
Authentik account dashboard
File management & sharing
Storage
We recommend Nextcloud as a replacement for the current Google Drive & Dropbox storage system.
Desktop, mobile and web clients are available so that you can access your files in whatever way suits you best. We do strongly recommend using the desktop client as a default because it is more reliable for syncing large files than the web interface.
Nextcloud can be extended with plugins which are officially developed by the project and remain stable. One such plugin is the calendar, which can be synced into a client such as Thunderbird.
Nextcloud provides fine-grained access control and user groups. Files can be shared internally, withing specific groups or publicly. Several options are available for sharing such as read-only shares, password protected shares or publicly accessible drag & drop upload shares.
Nextcloud web interface
Documents
There are many possible workflows. In this section we lay out some additional options which should be considered carefully.
Similarly to Google Drive, Nextcloud does provide functionality for opening and editing files and spreadsheets collaboratively in a browser. However, it is slow. We provide a simple online demo here.
We recommend using a Nextcloud desktop client and syncing the files to your computer. From there, the files can be edited with Libreoffice and automatically re-synced to Nextcloud. A possible work flow is to join an online video call, share screen and talk through the document together while only one person edits the file. This is however not ideal for moments which do require collaborative editing.
For these moments, we have begun recommending Outline which many of our clients use as well as internally at Autonomic (we made this document in Outline! 😄). It has a clean and intuitive interface that makes editing documents together in real-time very smooth. Outline is structured as a wiki and makes organising documents a breeze. However it does not syncronize with Nextcloud so this would be a separate collection of documents.
Outline doesn’t support editing the usual .odt / .xls / .docx file formats.
A final option which is popular within artist communities is Etherpad. An online demo is provided here. Etherpad is a very performant collaborative editor. However, it lacks the document organisation features of Outline. Etherpad also doesn’t importing files for editing.
The Outline web interface where a document is being edited by 3 people
Chat system
We recommend Matrix as an alternative to the current Slack chat system.
One of the main advantages of Matrix is the high quality clients available on all major operating systems, both mobile and desktop as well as web-based. We recommend Element as the most reliable, polished and usable Matrix chat client.
Matrix is a federated system like email. This means that if other arts organisations were to use Matrix as well then you could speak to each other without creating a new account on their system (just like you can email from @gmail.com to @hotmail.com). The core of this idea is to avoid creating new data silos. As a concrete example, if Constant were to use Matrix, then @donna:neondigitalarts.com could chat with @femke:constantvzw.org directly.
To begin with, we recommend not opening up for federation. Instead, taking time to learn how to use Element and organise internally.
Element integrates directly with Jitsi and it is possible to initiate one-to-one or group video/audio calls. Fine-grained permission and access controls are available.
Element desktop, our recommended Matrix client
Additional concerns
Training
As requested, we will run 2 hands-on training sessions. Further training sessions can be organised on-demand as budget / time allows for.
Documentation
We can provide helpful documentation on request and upload it on your document editing tool of choice. This can be useful to save NEoN staff time searching for useful clients, tricks & tips, best practices, etc.
Hosting
We make use of Hetzner as a server hosting provider. Their servers are located in Germany.
Support & Maintenance
Once the server is set up and the tools are online and running, we will need to take care of them.
This typically consists of two concerns, 1) the server upgrades 2) the app upgrades. Autonomic maintenance and support is built in to the costings provided below.
Please see our service level agreement for further details.
GDPR
Depending on needs, we have GDPR documents ready which we can use for this project. If specific research and GDPR support is required to work out further legal documents, we can undertake this and bill at the agreed hourly rate.
⏲ Timetable
Retracted for public sharing
💰 Costs & billing
Retracted for public sharing
🔚 Conclusion
Thank you for your interest in working with us!
We think this can be a great project which strengthens the UK arts sector, taking the initiative to implement digital reforms in collaboration with technology co-operatives and showing what is possible.